|
Cognac and Health |
1- Introduction
2- Cognac
& Diabetics
3- Cognac &
Cardio-vascular Disease
4- Cognac
& Digestion
5- Cognac &
Obesity
6- Cognac & Cancer
|
Consumers world wide are becoming more aware of health
issues relating to food and drink and have a growing interest in
the extra health benefits of the products they buy.
The following is an attempt to highlight some of the more detailed
studies that have relevence to people who appreciate and enjoy Cognac.
At the same time it is important to make some general comments to
put these studies on health and Cognac in to context.
Cognac is a by law in France a strong alcoholic drink with a minimum
of 40 % Alc vol which the consumer has the option to be take straight
as a digestive after food as in the case of the older XO types or
diluted with varying degrees of ice and water as aperitif as per
the younger VSOP VS Cognac types. However in spite of the flexibility
of Cognac it is always subject to the normal caution that it should
be always taken in moderation.
Cognac is unique product which only originates from
the region of Charente in France and should not be confused with
brandy ,it is exclusivily made from white grapes and is as much
a product of the climate and land as the people itself. Its manufacture
is subject to very strict Appellation controls which are also enshrined
in local and national French law decrees that go back May 1909,
though Cognac as been produced to high and excacting standard since
the 17th Centuary.
These laws and decrees cover every aspect of Cognac
manufacturer even to the extent that 90 % of the grapes must be
Ugni Blanc, Folle Blanche, Colombard these grapes traditionally
have a low sugar and alcoholic content: and it was for this very
reason the Dutch in the 16th Centuary found these wines did not
travel well and were forced to invent ways of extending their life
and hit on transforming them into'burnt wine' - 'brandwijn' to preserve
them.
Cognac by French law bans additives, this is so controlled
that even additives such as Sulphates which are now taken for granted
by the consumer in red wine and can cause alergic reactions in very
special cases or the practise of adding additional quantities of
sugar which are found in many other spirits and do increase artificially
the calorific value of these products which can go up to a value
of 91kcal and above;
These practises are completely prohibited in the
making of Cognac it is therefore not suprising that Cognac it is
therefore regarded by many as one of the purest and natural products
available today.
Cognac has a exceedingly low natural sugar content(
0.32 g ie 1,28 kcal for 4cl dose) and levels are monitored throughout,
fermentation is restricted to less than 2-3 weeks , the banning
of the continuous press and the use of the slower traditional horizontal
plate press systems . Even at this stage the early grape juice has
only approximately 8% of alcohol by volume .
Cognac under French law must be double distilled,
it has no other option to it , it must also use the smaller Charentais
Copper Stills the only type that can be used which only have a maximum
load of 25 hl so quality can be properly monitored in small production
units. The whole distilling process by law has to be completed by
the 31st March 5- 6 months after the picking of the grapes in September
/ October, the rest of the time amazingly the Charentais Stills
lie idle in a quite silence for the next 6 months to ensure that
the quality is never compromised.
These French government decrees go as far as to specify
the actual type of wood used. This must be oak and traditionally
comes from the Troncais and Limousin forests in France.These woods
are preferred because it has be found over the years that Cognac
can extract more tannin from these than any other type of wood.It
also adds bouquet, natural balance and taste of vanilla to the older
Cognac. Even the age of the eau d'vie and the aging of the Cognac
in oak casks is decreed as a minimum of 2 years for VS, 4 Years
for VSOP, 6 Years for a XO it is only then , it finally becomes
Cognac. Due to the traditonal system of ageing in Cognac which means
oak casks are rarely emptied and tend to be kept half full to keep
the barrel's condition this means that the average age of Cognac
often far exceed these minimums.
This is particularly the case with some private family
cognac producers for example like Pierre Boullmer Extra Age Cognac
which is certainly among this group Pierre Boullmer VS is approximately
aminimum of 4 years, Pierre Boullmer is VSOP 8 years and the XO
Premier Grand Cru over the 30 years this does mean these types of
Cognacs are allowed the maximum time to benefit from the aging process.
Lastly it is important to stress that with the very
strong controls that Cognac obviously has both at government and
local levels of its processes and the mature and proven infrastructure
of the Cognac Appellations are well placed to insure that its vines,
grapes are kept free from genetically modified experiments. This
stituation is not so clear with many other spirits who tend have
raw materials such as grain and sugar cane which are also used predominantly
in the food industry rather than the drinks industry and therefore
are under increasing and considerable economic pressure to experiment
in cheaper genetically modified foods (GM FOODS) which due to
their very nature are difficult to control.
Recently a few experiental studies
and research has been carried out on Cognac and here are some of
the following examples:
Différentes études expérimentales ont
été récemment menées sur le Cognac ;
on peut ainsi citer à titre d'exemple :
CHAUGIER et al. (1998)
SFRI Laboratoire (Société Française de Recherche
et d'Investissement) Bordeaux - France
The antioxidant effect of Cognac has only recently
been able to be seen due to a new clinical test called the 3 D Test
( Damage DNA Detection). This effect is is mainly due to the constituents
found in oak wood particularly Ellagic Acid which has a strong antioxidant
activity protecting the DNA from antioxidative damage.
Le pouvoir antioxydant du Cognac est démontré
grâce au nouveau test 3D (Damage DNA Detection). Cet effet
est dû notamment aux composants du bois de chêne et
en particulier à l'acide ellagique qui à une forte
activité antioxydante protègeant l'ADN contre les
dommages oxydatifs des radicaux libres.
ARIMOTO et al. (1998)
Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Graduate School of Natural
Sciences and Technology, Okayama University, Tsushima, Okayama -
Japan
Unlike Ethanol and a few other alcohols, it has been
proved that Cognac has an antimutagenic effect against a specific
group of cancerous substances. This effect is particularly due to
the numerious Polyphenolic constituents contained in Cognac, after
aging in oak barrel.
Contrairement à l'éthanol et à certains
alcools, il a été démontré notamment
pour le Cognac, un effet antimutagène contre un groupe de
substances cancérigènes. Cet effet est dû en
particulier aux nombreux composés polyphénoliques
contenus dans le Cognac, grâce à un vieillissement
en fûts de chêne.
DAPORTO,et.al.(2000)
Dipartimento di Scienze degli Alimentari, University of Udine -
ltaly
The effect of Cognac in reducing the hardening of
the arteries has been tested and it has been shown that the more
heavily weighted molecules of Polyphenols contained in Cognac are
one of the main agents for chemical roots trappers or anti-root
activity
L'activité antiradicalaire de quelques Cognacs a été
testée, et il a été démontré
que les polyphénols de haut poids moléculaire présents
dans le Cognac sont les principaux responsables de l'activité
"piégeurs de radicaux" (scavenger)
|
2- COGNAC & DIABETICS ( Cognac & diabète
) :
|
The negative effect of alcohol in Dibetes: Alcohol increase the
" Hypoglycemic" effect which is found particularly in
people suffering from Diabetes which increases the likelyhood of
comas so many Diabetics are advised to eat small and regular quantites
of sugar to balance this effect: see note one.
L'effet négatif de l'alcool : L'alcool a un effet hypoglycémique
qui est majoré dans les cas de diabète. Aussi, en
cas de consommation d'alcool, il convient de manger de petites quantités
de sucres lents, pour éviter l'hypoglycémie.
One advantage of Cognac is that Cognac is very low
in sugar content ( 0.32 g ie 1,28 Kcal for 4cl dose) this is very
small when this is compared to the calorific value found in alcohol(91Kcal)
and this has proved important in the study of Diabetes- Obesity
syndrome see note 1)
D'autre part, le cognac contient une faible quantité
de sucre (0,32 g soit 1,28 Kcal pour une dose de 4 cl), négligeable
par rapport à l'apport calorique dû à l'alcool
(91 Kcal).
The Positive Effect of Alcohol: Studies have shown
that moderate alcohol consumption has a favourable effect on the
surounding areas of insulin resistance and particilarly on the adipocytes.
L'effet positif de l'alcool : Des études font ressortir
un rôle favorable à la consommation modérée
d'alcool sur l'insulinorésistance périphérique,
notamment des adipocytes.
Also, polyphenols contained in Cognac have a vascular
-protector effect due to the antioxidantes properties.
Par ailleurs, les polyphénols du Cognac ont un rôle
vasculo-protecteur du fait de leurs propriétés antioxydantes.
1. BELL
(DS.) Alcohol and the NIDDM patient, Diabetes Care 1996
May ; 19 (5) : 509-13
AL QATARI (M.), SMIH (MF.), TABERNER (PV.) Chronic ethanol
consumption ameliorates the maturity-onset-diabetes-obesity
syndrome in CBA mice, Alcohol 1996 January ; 31 (1) : 89-99
|
3- COGNAC & CARDIO-VASCULAR DISEASE ( Cognac
et maladies cardiovasculaires ) :
|
In the case of a moderate alcohol consumption, the
protection effect of polyphneols & ethanol from cardiovascular
diseases are shown: see note 2 below.
Les effets protecteurs de l'éthanol et des polyphénols
contre les maladies cardiovasculaires sont démontrés,
dans le cas d'une consommation modérée d'alcool.
Indeed, alcohol in moderate doses has positive effects
on the fat or grease build up mechanisms and the formation of blood
clots, limiting cardiovascular disease risks.The polyphenolic constituents
assist in this effect of antioxidants and anti coagulants.
En effet, l'alcool à dose modérée agit
sur les mécanismes des graisses et de formation des caillots,
limitant ainsi les risques de maladies cardiovasculaires. Les composés
polyphénoliques ont des effets antioxydants et anticoagulants
bénéfiques.
However, keep in mind that alcohol consumption has
to be controlled , limited, in the case of obesity and high blood
pressure.
Il faut toutefois rappeler que la consommation doit être
limitée dans les cas d'obésité et d'hypertension
artérielle.
Cognac belongs to that sector of alcohol drinks that
are rich in phenolic constituents with high antioxidant properties
as red wine and can contribute to reducing risks.
Le Cognac fait donc partie des boissons alcoolisées
contenant des composés phénoliques à propriété
hautement antioxydante, au même titre que le vin rouge, et
peut contribuer significativement à la réduction des
risques cardiovasculaires.
2. CARANDO (S.) et al. Athérosclérose:
Physiopathologie Boissons alcoolisées et cardiopathies
ischémiques. Cahier de nutrition et de diététique,
1998 33 182-187. Editions Massons
CRIQUI (MH.), Do know cardiovascular risk factors mediate
the effect of alcohol on cardiovascular disease ? Novartis
Found Symposium, 1998; 216; 159-167
IMHOF (A.) et al. Effect of alcohol consumption on systemic
markers of inflammation. Lancet 2001 March 10; 357 (9258)
: 763-7
GOLDBERG (DM.), HOFFMAN (B.), YANG (J.), SOLEAS (J.) Phenol
constituents, furans, and total antioxidant status of distilled
spirits. J Agric Food Chem 1999 Oct; 47 (10) ; 3978-85
|
4- COGNAC & DIGESTION ( Cognac et digestion)
:
|
Ethanol has a double action on the digestive system but is very
different from the action on cardiovascular problems.
L'éthanol agit d'une double façon sur le système
digestif, mais de façon plus nuancée que pour les
problèmes cardiovasculaires.
These possible effects on the digestion lead to advise an moderate
Cognac consumption. However, the high quantity of polyphenols contained
seem to play a role in adding to to the protection effect of the
gastric mucus membrane and is a extra protection factor.
Les effets potentiels sur la digestion amènent à
recommander une consommation modérée de Cognac. Toutefois,
la présence de polyphénols en quantités importantes,
qui semblent jouer un rôle de protection de la muqueuse gastrique,
constitue un facteur protecteur potentiel supplémentaire.
|
5- COGNAC & OBESITY ( Cognac et obèsité)
:
|
It has been shown that a moderate consumption of alcohol has no
significant effect on men's weight and even has a mild slimming
effect on women.
Il a été démontré que la consommation
modérée d'alcool n'a aucun effet sur le poids des
hommes et a même un faible effet amaigrissant chez les femmes.
On the other hand it is strongly advised to avoid drinking alcohol
where there are hepatic and liver related problems and risks
En revanche, il est fortement déconseillé aux
obèses de consommer de l'alcool étant donné
les risques de problèmes hépatiques qui y sont liés.
|
6- COGNAC & CANCER ( Cognac et cancer ) : |
Though alcohol, in the case of moderate consumption, protects the cardiovascular
system from disease and aids the digestion it can increase the risks of
cancer of the upper aerodigestive tract : see note 3.
Si l'alcool à faible dose protège contre les maladies
cardiovasculaires et améliore la digestion, en revanche, il augmente
les risques de cancer des voies aérodigestives supérieure
However,due to their antioxidants properties, polyphenols
are anticancerous and antimutagenic, protects from cells oxidative damage
including lipidic peroxudation. As Cognac is rich in in polyphenic constituents,
so it has been shown that the ellagic acid can inhibite cancer of the
lung, liver and oesophagus can as tests have shown: see note 3 below.
Toutefois, du fait de leurs propriétés antioxydantes,
les polyphénols sont anticancérigènes et antimutagènes.
Ils protègent des dommages oxydatifs des cellules incluant la péroxudation
lipidique. Or le Cognac est particulièrement riche en composés
polyphénoliques. Ainsi, il est démontré que l'acide
ellagique peut inhiber les cancers du poumon, du foie et de l'sophage
chez les rongeurs.
3. YANG (CS.) et al. Inhibition of cancerogenesis
by dietary polyphenolic compounds. Annu Rev Nutr 2001; 21 : 381-406
CHUNG (KT.) et al. Tannins and human health : a review. Crit Rev
Food Sci Nutr 1998 Aug ; 38 (6) : 421-464
KAUL (A.), KHANDUJA (KL.) Polyphenols inhibit promotional phase
of tumorigeneris : Relevance of superoxide radicals Nutr Cancer
1998 ; 32(2) : 81-5
STONER
(GD.) MUKHTAR (H.) Polyphenols as cancer chemopreventive agents.
J Cell Biochem Suppl 1995; 22 : 69-80
> Last up dated on 10/5/02 / www.pierreboullmer.com
/ e-mail : Pierre Boullmer
|